I tried to have anal sex with my girl and it was too tight to penetrate, how tell her to open her butt cheeks as much as she can; put more lube. Anal fissures are categorized as small tears in the anal surface lining and may Rectum pressure or pain could be caused by many different. Here, experts answer everything you've wanted to know about anal sex. But it can also raise a bunch of intimate questions you might feel too . When it comes to lube, you pretty much have three options: oil-based, . Once your partner gets past that tight anal sphincter, there's plenty of room in your.